How Squarestate Works
SquareState

Connect with Squarestate


Gotta Tip???
Go to the archive
Advertise on Squarestate
Online Voter Registration!





Search




Advanced Search


New Study Show No Difference Between Driving High And Straight

by: Bill Egnor AKA Something The Dog Said

Mon Jun 07, 2010 at 11:39:17 AM MST


As we start to really talk about the legalization of marijuana there is a false equivalence that has to be addressed. Marijuana is an intoxicant but that does not mean it is like alcohol. Legalization advocates have had to deal with a lot of misinformation over the years about pot. The false correlation that pot itself lead to other more addictive and damaging drugs (when the reality was the correlation is about illegality of pot, not the affects of using it), the concept that it somehow makes a user less productive or permanently impairs cognitive functions.

Luckily there is new and emerging science that shows this is not the case. There was a recent study which looked at the affect of being high on marijuana and driving. The University of Iowa did a small double blind study to see if how smoking pot would affect the ability to drive.  

Bill Egnor AKA Something The Dog Said :: New Study Show No Difference Between Driving High And Straight
They took a group of 85 volunteers (50 men, 35 women) and ran them through a simulator for baseline comparison. They then gave some cigarettes with THC and some without and repeated the testing.  The test looked at basic driving, distracted driving and collision avoidance senarios.

The result was that there was no significant difference between pre-pot baseline or the performance between those who were high and those who had received the placebo. The major difference was that the high drivers were more likely to slow down in situations where the straight drivers did not. Since we know that there is a correlation between average driving speed and accidents, this tends to indicate that stoned drivers would actually be safer than none stoned drivers.

Of course this is a small study, but it is far from the only one that has been performed on driving and marijuana use. Take this study from 1999 at the University of Toronto. It directly compares the affects of alchol and marijuana on drivers and finds:

Both substances impair performance," Smiley says. "However, the more cautious behaviour of subjects who received marijuana decreases the drug's impact on performance. Their behaviour is more appropriate to their impairment, whereas subjects who received alcohol tend to drive in a more risky manner."

We must keep hammering home the fact that booze and pot are while both are intoxicants are not the same in their short-term and long-term affects. The pro-prohibition forces are going to keep trying to conflate the two, and driving accidents are going to be a big area of contention. The science shows that these two substances should not be equated but that is not going to stop them. Right now there are laws being considered that would make testing positive for the use of pot while driving illegal. The issue here is that the markers for pot persist in the body far longer than those of alcohol.  Before the narrow minded forces of prohibition make this mistake we need to talk about the really affects of marijuana, not the "Refer Maddness" BS that moralist think is the reality of the use of this drug.

It is time to legalize pot. Regulate it, tax it but don't treat it as some kind of super drug or booze.

The floor is yours.  

Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Someone get Chris Romer on the line
oh wait, he's napping. Do not disturb.

FYI "cigarettes with THC" are also called joints. ;)


the study also found
that the drivers in the control group were more likely to listen to whiny angry music while those with "THC cigarettes" all seemed to turn on Bob Marley.

Sorry Michael Bennet, but I'm a real person too

Not to mention
the unforeseen effects of questioning authority while the booze drinkers were seen laughing at commercials.  

[ Parent ]
And they found
that those drank the alcohol tended to sing louder and more off key along with the whiny angry music and that those that had the HTC just kind of mumbled their way through the songs, mostly by Bob Marley.

[ Parent ]
I can vouch for that.
40 years worth. What a bunch of bull shit that I or others are a menace to the rest of the drivers out there. I will continue to do the same as I always have and take my chances.

Legalize-of course!

Like most everything else we need this and should have gotten it years ago but we won't and we never will.

But we'll get plenty of war and death like the seven of ours killed today-no problem there and the bastards on our side who make the votes in DC will see to it!


Personally, I never drive straight ;)
I drive forward.

You make an important point about the difference in intoxication. You would never confuse being on vicodin with being drunk or dosing some diet pills with being stoned.  


I'd be curious to see the dose response effect.
Most people can drive reasonably well on one glass of beer.  A dozen is another story.

Just how high were the experimental subjects?

It seems plausible that the doses to which they were exposed was too low to have an effect, but that at some dose there would have been an effect.  They issue may not be "impairment" or "no impairment" but the threshold of impairment.


Squarestate.net is owned by Open Communications Colorado, LLC. and is not responsible for the opinions expressed outside of our own.
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Resources
Online Voter Registration!
Blog Roll
Abandon Your Car
American Indian Movement Colorado
Argusfest
The Bell
Big Media
Colorado Capitol Watch
Colorado Confluence Colorado Ethics Watch
Colorado Independent
Colorado Progressive Jewish News
Coloradopols
Congresspedia
Coyote Gulch
CritterThink
DemNotes
Denver Direct
Denver Voice
El Centro Humanitario
El Seminario
Great Education Colorado
La Voz
Lefty Blogs
Liberal Latina
Mario Solis-Marich
Mariowire
Outta the Cornfield
Pocho Blog
Politics West
Rocky Mountain Activist
Scholars and Rogues
Steam Powered Opinions
TriLakeDems
Ultimate Politics
Union Staff for Union
Democracy

Wash Park Prophet
WeatherDem - the blog
Wide Streets

Get Involved
Deep Green Resistance
Occupy Denver
Occupy Everywhere

What We Listen To
KUNC 91.5 FM
AM 760: Boulder's Progressive Talk
KCFR 1340 AM
KGNU 1390AM or 88.5FM
KRFC 88.9FM
Citizen Radio
MicCheckRadio
Democracy Now!
Progressive Voice
Colorado State Legislature

Reference
CoMaps.org
General Assembly
Prospector
Secretary of State
Tax Tracks
TRACER
WikiLeaks.org

Powered By
SoapBlox



Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.

SquareState.net is owned by Open Communications Colorado, LLC
Powered by: SoapBlox