How Squarestate Works
SquareState

Connect with Squarestate


Gotta Tip???
Go to the archive
Advertise on Squarestate
Online Voter Registration!





Search




Advanced Search


Bennet's second TV ad

by: StrykerK2

Fri Apr 02, 2010 at 11:36:13 AM MST


(Yikes! Some harsh criticisms of Michael Bennet's new television ad. WWRD?   - promoted by Fong)

Bennet released their second campaign video this morning.  My thoughts are below, but check it out yourself first:

Ok -- now that you've watched (and hopefully made up your own mind).  Here are my thoughts:

StrykerK2 :: Bennet's second TV ad
1) I do think it's a bit better than their first.  This may sound cruel, but it's important: he didn't really look awake for the first one.  He's much more alert and with it in this one (filmed same day and post coffee?).  Appearances are important.  I don't think the Bennet folks get that.

2) That said, it's still pretty poor.  With the money and access they have at their disposal, I was expecting them to be running top-notch professional ads.  The quick ones you throw together come later for responses and such.  This doesn't look very professionally done, but rather done in house or by a smaller company.  Who is their media consultant and how did they let this happen?

3) Wrong messenger.  Ok this will open up the "who is the real reformer" can of worms, but let's be honest here: we have a guy who is a sitting senator attacking Washington.  He cannot simultaneously be an outsider and an incumbent, no matter how hard he tries.  Ironically, he's funding the ad with those special interest dollars.

4) Not every Colorado candidate is a Salazar.  You don't have to be a rancher to get elected here, and please stop faking it.  He looks out of place in that Carhartt jacket.  Senator Bennet: I doubt you've ever spent time on a farm, and you certainly haven't worked as a truck driver.  These aren't requirements to be a Senator from Colorado, but again honesty at least helps.  You don't fake it well.

5) The messaging is stolen straight from Romanoff; Bennet seems confused even saying it.  The more that he tries to emulate Andrew the more he opens himself up for attack at a hypocrite.

Summary: Amateur.  I expected a lot more coming from the Bennet campaign.  What I don't get is what they are spending all this money on.  I mean they certainly are spending it, but they don't seem to be spending it well.  They are spending a lot of money to put these bad ads up on television: I can't imagine it's a good investment.

Tags: , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

You can be an outsider and be an incumbent
Republicans do it all the time. It's all in the perception which is what teevee ads create.

I like the horn honking. It makes me feel like he wants to pick me up.  


is it the hair that does it for you? n/t


Sorry Michael Bennet, but I'm a real person too

[ Parent ]
Good take on the add
I agree with all of it and Bennet has awesome hair

Agreed
Bennet has awesome Edward-esque hair.

I think that the ad just doesn't do anything for me.  He sounds hollow and disingenuous.  I think it probably would have looked better if he had people behind him instead of buildings.  Thats just me.


It's still better than Romanoff's ad
and how the insider/outsider perception occurs within the Romanoff/party insiders is irrelevant. You can't be the voice that reaches as far as an ad can.

And it's still better than Norton's or Buck's ad.

Besides, when was the last time a winning political ad was high art?  


What about this Mike Gravel ad

Oh, you said winning.


[ Parent ]
Winning is important
though I do think this video reached beyond its targeted audience.

The world just wasn't ready, Mike.  


[ Parent ]
The problem isn't the ad
It's an OK ad (not great, not awful, I've seen better and worse), but that isn't the problem.

The problem (for his opponents) is that Bennet is using these ads to define himself as an outsider who will try to fix what's wrong with Washington, DC. We aren't the audience for these ads; the audience for these ads are the larger population of voters who will vote in August and November. That population doesn't really know either Democratic candidate, and to the degree they know Norton, they probably assume she's the former Interior secretary.

That's why so many people, including myself, harp on the fundraising piece; Bennet has the money to spend to define himself, which neither Romanoff nor the Republicans have.

The ads don't have to be magnificent. They just have to work. Again, we may think they're bad or OK or amateur, but we're not the intended audience.

ad astra, per aspera // keep calm & carry on


You are completly right
It is all about targeting at this point and this add (though not poorly done, and his hair does look fantastic!) is the equivalent of doing a lit drop to every house in a neighborhood in May.

I shudder to even think about that. The loss of information, the lack of planning, the waste of money!

I think this add would work very well in October but for right now it is just a waste of money.

Senator Buck will give me a great sense of "Buyers Remorse" in the way that it would feel like my Senator was screwing me over.  


[ Parent ]
WWRD?
Viral video. That's free, right? Seriously though, if Romanoff could afford TV, he would be saying this exact same thing: "I'm the outsider, I'm the one who's going to fix the Senate."

The fact of the matter is that neither one of these men are outsiders. This is all just another huge argument over an area where both of these men are incredibly similar.


Romanof says everyone but himself is corrupt
That's the difference. Romanoff believes his own rhetoric.
He believes it so much so that he told my best friend's brother that he was a civil rights lawyer, when he hasn't even passed the bar in any state of the union.

really ray?
I love these stories -- so and so told my brother's friend's dog's roommate something.  Cut the crap.

Sorry Michael Bennet, but I'm a real person too

[ Parent ]
Sigh...
Here's what Romanoff's campaign website says:

Romanoff took an early interest in civil rights. As a student, he learned about the Southern Poverty Law Center's efforts to combat Ku Klux Klan and neo-Nazi groups. The Center's Klanwatch Project and a state civil rights agency became two of his first employers.

After earning a bachelor's degree at Yale, Romanoff set off for Costa Rica and Nicaragua, where he taught English in rural high schools. After coming home, he earned a master's degree in public policy at Harvard and a law degree at the University of Denver.


I suppose that if you squint real hard, a JD might sound like having passed the bar.  I think someone wants to hear things a certain way.

It's here: http://www.andrewromanoff.com/...


[ Parent ]
Squarestate.net is owned by Open Communications Colorado, LLC. and is not responsible for the opinions expressed outside of our own.
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Resources
Online Voter Registration!
Blog Roll
Abandon Your Car
American Indian Movement Colorado
Argusfest
The Bell
Big Media
Colorado Capitol Watch
Colorado Confluence Colorado Ethics Watch
Colorado Independent
Colorado Progressive Jewish News
Coloradopols
Congresspedia
Coyote Gulch
CritterThink
DemNotes
Denver Direct
Denver Voice
El Centro Humanitario
El Seminario
Great Education Colorado
La Voz
Lefty Blogs
Liberal Latina
Mario Solis-Marich
Mariowire
Outta the Cornfield
Pocho Blog
Politics West
Rocky Mountain Activist
Scholars and Rogues
Steam Powered Opinions
TriLakeDems
Ultimate Politics
Union Staff for Union
Democracy

Wash Park Prophet
WeatherDem - the blog
Wide Streets

Get Involved
Deep Green Resistance
Occupy Denver
Occupy Everywhere

What We Listen To
KUNC 91.5 FM
AM 760: Boulder's Progressive Talk
KCFR 1340 AM
KGNU 1390AM or 88.5FM
KRFC 88.9FM
Citizen Radio
MicCheckRadio
Democracy Now!
Progressive Voice
Colorado State Legislature

Reference
CoMaps.org
General Assembly
Prospector
Secretary of State
Tax Tracks
TRACER
WikiLeaks.org

Powered By
SoapBlox



Active Users
Currently 0 user(s) logged on.

SquareState.net is owned by Open Communications Colorado, LLC
Powered by: SoapBlox